No OTA HDTV For You

We got a new TV, but more on that later.

Since the TV that we got has an ATSC tuner inside, I wanted to give it a try. I did not have high hopes for getting OTA DTV and OTA HDTV. But, I had to give it a shot. I read that the el cheapo indoor RCA “rabbit ears” and loop indoor antenna were actually the best ones to use — if you’re not going to be doing the whole outdoors-on-the-rooftop thing. So, I picked up an $8 RCA indoor antenna (ANT110) from Fry’s and gave it a shot.

To my surprise, the TV actually got nine stations. These were from antennas that are within 20 miles of my house. The other broadcast antennas (according to antennaweb.org) are more than 30 miles away — those stations I couldn’t get. The nine stations were a mix of Spanish-language channels and public broadcast. There was one independent broadcast station also. All stations were broadcasting their standard 4:3 analog stuff in DTV format — meaning, no HDTV signals and I was getting the same stuff as I get on my Dish.

Oh wells, it was worth a try. The antenna is going back to Fry’s. I’ll have to explore other ways of getting HD content — paying an extra $10 a month for HD stuff is not costly, but it’s not something I want to do either. A Bluray machine would be nice so that I could watch HD stuff from Netflix.


  1. Ryan Grove

    When I lived in Oregon, my Radio Shack bunny ears had no trouble picking up every single local station that had an HD broadcast. In San Jose, I get nothing. Not a single station. I’m not sure what it is about this area. The hills maybe?

  2. Bigmac

    When we lived in San Jose, near Vally Fair Mall, I picked up a cheap rooftop antenna from Radio Shack. We were able to get every major network and a ton of PBS in HD (and all the espanol you can shake el palo at). If you’re able to do the rooftop thing, it’s a pretty good deal.

  3. mookie

    Well, KQED-HD did not start broadcasting HD content until 5pm. That’s the only HD channel that I can get. I just tuned in and found some 1080i goodness. Oh wow, it’s very impressive. The quality of the picture is fantabulous.

    Ryan, I think it’s because of the hills and because all the major networks affiliates have their broadcast antennas way up in the North Bay.

    Bigmac, I’m thinking about it! after seeing the PBS HD stuff.

  4. sista

    What are you going to do with your old TV?

  5. Mike Surma

    I bought a PS3 to use as my BluRay player. It works very well and is much quieter then the XBox 360. :) Then made use of the my discount at Warner Bros to augmented my collection of movies.

  6. Andrew S

    Try the silver sensor antenna (small/indoor), or better yet, a big antenna in your attic (if you have an attic).

  7. chuck

    Your not going to get HD channels over the air with a regular rabbit ear antenna. You have to buy a HD antenna and have a HDTV.

    http://www.bestbuy.com/site/olspage.jsp?id=abcat0107006&type=category

  8. mookie

    Chuck,

    “HD antenna” is actually just a marketing ploy — there is no difference between a regular antenna and an “HD antenna” since they both do the same thing: Receive signals off the air (UHF and VHF). So, the argument that rabbit ear antennas will *never* work is not true. Like Ryan observed, if you’re close to your broadcast antennas, a pair of regular rabbit ears will work just fine — heck, there are a few rabbit ears listed in that Best Buy link you put in your comment, and again, the “HD” part is just marketing.

    -Mookie

  9. Davor7

    With OTA HD in mind and that we will have to get a box for them, I haven’t been able to find a OTA HD box with component outputs. I have an older Panasonic HDTV (without the tuner but with component inputs) and don’t want to crumbup the HD quality with composite or RF hookups. Any ideas?

  10. aou

    Chuck: not true. HDTV signal can be and are broadcasted on the same frequencies as analogue TV. More than this - politicians are talking about
    freeing up some frequencies, by moving all the HDTV broadcsts down to the frequencies where all the phasing out analogue signals lives.

    I build myself an antenna from a beer can and it works just fine for all the Toronto HDTV signals.
    http://diyfreetv.blogspot.com/2008/01/how-to-build-tv-antenna-from-beer-can.html

    So good-old rabbit years should work as well. Especially after Analog shutdown in US.

Leave a Comment